BTSLet’s talk

Good idea. Awkward execution.

Good ads, bad ads: lessons from a creative team review

Our creative team reacts to advertising examples and discusses humour, brand recognition, visual ideas and the difference between clever and clear.

Watch the full conversation on YouTube ↗ · Creative Three Media channel ↗

An idea has to survive the audience

In The Good VS The Bad, the team brings advertising examples to a shared review and reacts to them together. The discussion moves between effective humour, strong visual concepts, brand recognition and ideas that do not land as intended.

That is a useful exercise for a business planning its own campaign. An idea can sound magnificent in a meeting and still confuse the person who encounters it between a weather update and a video of a dog.

Clever is not the same as clear

The team debates visual metaphors, changing brand identities and examples where the point can be missed if the execution moves too quickly. These are reminders to test comprehension, not just whether colleagues like the concept.

Show a rough version to someone outside the project. Ask what they think it means and which business it belongs to. If your explanation takes longer than the advert, there may be a little work left to do.

Make the memorable part belong to you

Familiar examples in the discussion include the Cadbury gorilla and an advert built around Snoop Dogg’s smoke-related announcement. The team explores how music, curiosity and a reveal can create attention.

The lesson is not to copy those campaigns. It is to understand the connection between the setup, the payoff and the brand. A distinctive idea should still help people recognise the advertiser, rather than leaving them with a great story about an unknown company.

Review the risk as well as the punchline

The conversation also considers ideas that may offend or fail because the creators become too attached to their pitch. Bring different perspectives into a review before committing to production.

Ask whether the humour fits the audience, whether the message is accurate and whether a short version still makes sense without the long one. For a practical starting point, use our creative brief guide and explore planning a TV commercial. Watch the full team review for the examples and reactions that prompted these lessons. A good creative meeting should improve the idea, not merely applaud whoever brought biscuits.

Explore more full-length conversations on the Creative Three Media YouTube channel, or talk to our Belfast team about your next project.

More good thinking →

Put the idea
to work.

Bring us your brief, your questions or the project you want to make better.

Start a conversation